You are here

Silence Movie Review 2017: Religious Overkill

Silence Movie 2017

Two quick points on why Martin Scorsese’s evangelical fervor must be debated. One, for a benign believer with a disinclination for proselytizing or religious conversion, the very premise of converting another man to your faith is distasteful. Also, the 1600s were barbaric days and it’s patently unfair to use the savage torture of those days to appeal to today’s refined sensitivities. Therefore, when the filmmaker seeks empathy for the Christian Japanese and their priests who were forced with inhuman cruelty to step on Jesus’ face and declare themselves apostates, the prime reaction is, why were you forcing your religion in someone else’s country in the first place?

There’s a dialogue-debate between the Japanese Inquisitor and fanatically religious Portuguese padre Rodrigues which reinforces the thought that Christians believed their God was superior to all others and thus, it was their holy duty to convert the whole world. Now that’s a belief which won’t find too many takers in a millennium that’s far more inclusive than it was in the 1600s.

Two young priests, Rodrigues and Garupe, set out to Japan to find their missing mentor Father Ferreira. It was rumored that he had turned apostate, given up his God, and settled down with a Japanese wife. Unable to accept that as the gospel truth, the two padres surreptitiously enter the land of the Rising Sun.

What they find are Japanese converts who have to practice their new faith in secrecy as they’re hounded by the Emperor’s enforcers. But the real targets are the padres who must abandon their God and their mission to save others from the cruelty.

Martin Scorsese takes his own time, 2hrs 41 minutes, to unfold his tale of religious persecution, luxuriating in the inhumanity of the Japanese who forcefully thwart all attempts to wean them away from Buddhism to embrace Christianity.

Sprinkling water from hot springs on open flesh, wrapping Christian girls in dry hay and drowning them or dangling men upside down in pits, Scorsese shows it all. It seems to particularly disturb him that the Japanese burnt the dead and didn’t give them a Christian burial. 

Scorsese redeems the apostates with the last shot of the padre’s cremation that reveals what his faith really was. He also has a tribute at the end which reads: ‘To Christian Japanese and their pastors’ which sums up the religiosity that powers this film. 

Andrew Garfield as Padre Rodrigues and Liam Neeson as Father Ferreira blend in with the times as they go through their roles with required fervor, frown, and inner frustration.  Technically, the film is beautiful. The locations have tranquil beauty even if the proceedings are harsh. Both caught with efficiency by DOP Rodrigo Pietro. 

For an indulgent film that’s out of sync with contemporary thought but would appeal to the zealously religious, Silence gets a 3* rating

Also Read

Keanu Reeves
16 Feb,2017

Directed by Chad Stahelski, the second installment of John Wick starring Keanu Reeves is about the 'Boogeyman' John Wick who has been dragged from his quiet retired life to pay his last favor to his makers

Everything Everything trailer
15 Feb,2017

The first trailer of Everything Everything is a very good blend of romance and coming-of-age story. The trailer is so amazing that in the end, it will surely leave a cheeky smile on your face! Take a look at the first trailer released by MGM

Teen Titans
11 Feb,2017

Teen Titans are going to make their solo appearance after their successful team-up with the Justice League

09 Feb,2017

Savior Jackie Chan is here to review and save Ninja Go along with Dave Franco, Michael Peña, Fred Armisen, Kumail Nanjiani, Zach Woods and Abbi Jacobson

Iron Fist
08 Feb,2017

Danny Rand is back and with his training in Ku'n Lu'n and his Iron Fist the last defender is all set to make the world a better place

Samurai Jack
07 Feb,2017

Jack's battle with Akku ended 50 years back but the war is still not over. He is back and this time he has to overcome his inner demons before taking the battle to the villain

Resident Evil: The Final Chapter
03 Feb,2017

Resident Evil: The Final Chapter is a 2017 science fiction action horror film written and directed by Paul W. S. Anderson. It is the sequel to Resident Evil: Retribution (2012) and the sixth and final installment in the Resident Evil film series, which is loosely based on the Capcom survival horror video game series Resident Evil

Kung Fu Yoga Movie Review 2017
03 Feb,2017

Kung Fu Yoga is a 2017 action-adventure comedy film directed by Stanley Tong. The film is a Chinese-Indian co-production of Taihe Entertainment and Shinework Pictures. Featuring original music composed by Nathan Wang and additional music composed by Komail and Shivaan

Matt Damon
02 Feb,2017

The Great Wall is a 2016 epic historical fiction action-adventure monster film directed by Zhang Yimou and written by Tony Gilroy, Carlo Bernard, Doug Miro to name a few. The film stars Matt Damon, Jing Tian, Pedro Pascal, Willem Dafoe and Andy Lau as the lead

I Don’t Wanna Live Forever, Zayn Malik, Taylor Swift
27 Jan,2017

Taylor Swift and Zayn Malik's new music video for Fifty Shades Darker, ‘I Don't Wanna Live Forever’ is finally out! Check out what did the song really missed

Logan, X23
20 Jan,2017

Logan new trailer is here and Hugh Jackman seems to be doing everything to make his last stint as Wolverine a memorable one. But this Logan has a competition this time

Power Rangers
20 Jan,2017

The Power Rangers are back with their second trailer, and it sure unveils many things that we were expecting from the first trailer

The Crew
20 Jan,2017

Flight Crew or The Crew is the first Russian film to be released in India. Inspired by the 1979 Soviet film ‘Air Crew’, the English dub of Ekipazh is about a civilian airline crew which is trying to save survivors of an earthquake on a volcano island.

Kung Fu Yoga trailer
20 Jan,2017

Kung Fu Yoga features Jackie Chan, Sonu Sood and Disha Patani as the lead in this Indo-Chinese film. The trailer just got out and all we can say that the film has shown the audience glimpse of both Indian and Chinese cliched culture

The Founder, Micheal Keaton
19 Jan,2017

The Founder is a 2016 American biographical drama film directed by John Lee Hancock and written by Robert Siegel. The film stars Michael Keaton as Ray Kroc and portrays the story of his acquisition of the McDonald's fast food chain

Deepika Padudone, Vin Diesel
14 Jan,2017

xXx: Return of Xander Cage is a 2017 American action film directed by D. J. Caruso and written by F. Scott Frazier. The film stars, Vin Diesel, Donnie Yen, Deepika Padukone, Kris Wu, Ruby Rose, Tony Jaa, Nina Dobrev, and many other actors

06 Jan,2017

Passengers is a 2017 American science fiction adventure film directed by Morten Tyldum and written by Jon Spaihts. It stars Chris Pratt, Jennifer Lawrence, Michael Sheen, Laurence Fishburne and Andy García

A Monster Calls
05 Jan,2017

A Monster Calls is a 2017 fantasy drama film directed by J. A. Bayona and written by Patrick Ness, based on his novel. It stars Sigourney Weaver, Felicity Jones, Toby Kebbell, Lewis MacDougall and Liam Neeson.

Assassin’s Creed
30 Dec,2016

Assassin's Creed is a 2016 action adventure film based on the video game franchise of the same name. Check out the movie review for the same!

SING Movie Review 2016
29 Dec,2016

Sing is a 2016 American 3D animated musical-comedy film which is produced by Illumination Entertainment and has been directed and written by Garth Jennings. The film stars the voices of Matthew McConaughey, Reese Witherspoon, Seth MacFarlane